I just recently used a $30 Amazon gift certificate from my parents to purchase “Clerks X” the 10 year anniversary edition of Kevin Smith’s first film.
When I was in college I worked at a Video Store (VisArt Video on Elliot Rd. in Chapel Hill, NC), which was attached to a newsstand. I never once saw “Clerks” while I worked there. It was kind of a running thing that every single person there who found out would say “and you work in a video store!”
So, once I moved away, I rented it one night, and okay, so it was pretty amazing. I became quite the Kevin Smith fan.
More importantly for myself, though, was the accidental, and seemingly unrelated discovery of Gregory McDonald’s “Fletch” books. The first book was, of course, the basis of the Chevy Chase movie, which, while funny, is nothing in comparison to the book. The books are more subtle, and rich, and the ending of the film makes I.M. Fletcher seem like a standup guy, whereas the end of the book makes him seem like a normal human being.
McDonald, like Kevin Smith and Tarantino, doesn’t feel the need to make conversations actually relate to the plot. He understands that things happen which are sometimes unrelated. This was a major gripe I had about the film, after I read the book. In the movie, the two plots around which Fletch navigates his life end up being completely related. In the book, accidental happenstance brings them together purely because Fletch is involved with both. It’s far more creative, and far less formulaic than you would imagine.
It’s also a lot darker. Much darker, in fact, than the original version of Clerks, where Dante gets shot at the end.
[That ending by the way, which would even seem stark in French cinema (though I guess Scandinavian filmmakers could get away with it), bothers me from a strictly plot perspective. Why is Dante still there? The store is closed, they just cleaned up, and were locking up, but rather than doing a check of the register, and clearing up inventory after Randall left, he's sitting at the counter, reading a magazine. After working from 6am to midnight in this place, and going through the worst day of his life, he's still hanging out.]
McDonald eventually softened his blows a bit (a 13 year old drug addicted prostitute dying of an overdose and being buried in a shallow grave by the main character is, I suppose, hard to top) in his later works, though they were still edgy, and filled with interesting situations and witty dialog.
And apparently, it was that witty dialog that taught Kevin Smith how to write dialog. Which is why I was really excited about him writing and directing the new Fletch film, based on the Fletch Prequel “Fletch Won.” Unfortunately, that’s not happening any more, so now I’m not as excited. The film is, however, being done by the creator of “Scrubs” on NBC, which also has the same fast witty dialog, and I guess that’s a consolation. It could always have been done by Michael Bay, with an explosion every few minutes, and a completely CGI 7 foot tall Chevy Chase to reprise his role.
So in summery:
1) Clerks, good…
2) Gregory McDonald, good…
3) Original Clerks ending, confusing and Bergman-esque…
4) “Fletch” the novel, surprising and not always in a funny way…
5) Michael Bay, (sigh)
I just noticed that the 11th Fletch Book (actually the second book centered around his son), “Fletch Reflected” is now out in reprint from Vintage Books. It’s the only one I haven’t read. I most recently finished “Carioca Fletch,” which was one of the most enjoyable of the series.
In all honesty, if I had to make a recommendation, I would say my favorites, in order are:
1. “Confess, Fletch” - which has, in my opinion, the greatest opening chapter of any book I’ve yet read. It sets up a mystery, and does so in a strange, round about, but amusing way. It also introduces Francis Xavier Flynn, who went on to have his own series of books, which are also pretty good.
2. “Fletch” - The original, and as mentioned above, a very big surprise, especially if you’ve seen the movie.
3. “Fletch Won” - The basis of the upcoming movie (once it gets made).
4. “Carioca Fletch” - the actual sequel to the original “Fletch,” which would have made for a far more interesting sequel in the 80s than “Fletch Lives,” which is not based on any of the books.
I was hoping this post would be more coherent, but… Captain Power… angry Monkey… waffles